Dissociative Experiences Scale (DES-II)

Start the test

Test guides

DES-II validity and reliability

Review the original DES studies, the revised DES-II response format and what the historical cutoff of 30 can support in different populations.

Scientific evidence for the DES and DES-II

The scale's evidence has developed across decades, different response formats and different diagnostic targets. A sound interpretation names those distinctions instead of attaching one universal reliability or accuracy percentage to every use.

How to cite the 1993 multicenter study
AnalysisReported findingWhat to retain when citing it
Discriminant analysis, psychiatric subgroup of 88376% sensitivity and 85% specificityThese figures describe the classification analysis in that subgroup.
Separate threshold analysisAt 30, estimated positive predictive value of 17% under the study assumptionsThe base rate and diagnostic target are essential. The estimate is not an individual probability for all users.

What reliability can tell us

The original 1986 development study included clinical and non-clinical groups with 10–39 people per group. It reported good test–retest and split-half reliability and significant relationships between item scores and the overall score. These findings supported measuring dissociative experiences, but the development samples were small. [1]

Test–retest reliability concerns consistency across administrations under suitable conditions. Internal consistency concerns relationships among items. Neither establishes the cause of an experience or turns a total into a clinical diagnosis.

Know what was measured

Different answers, identical DES-II mean In fictional example A, all twenty-eight item ratings are twenty. In example B, fourteen item ratings are forty and fourteen are zero. Each set sums to five hundred and sixty. Dividing either sum by twenty-eight gives a DES-II mean of twenty. The experiences behind the total still need discussion.
Scoring rules and study context belong with every performance claim. [2]

What changed in DES-II?

Carlson and Putnam's 1993 update reviewed evidence on measurement and use and included a revised, easier-to-score form. DES-II offers the percentage choices in a different response format from the original line-marking approach. [2]

Historical findings about the DES remain relevant to the development of the measure. They should still be described as findings about the form and procedure actually studied. A new interface or translation should not acquire a performance claim solely by sharing the name.

The 1993 multicentre diagnostic study

Carlson and colleagues analysed 1,051 participants and a subgroup of 883 designed to better represent a typical psychiatric facility's diagnostic base rates. The target was the condition then called multiple personality disorder, now generally termed dissociative identity disorder. [3]

Discriminant analysis in the more representative subgroup gave 76% sensitivity and 85% specificity. The paper also separately evaluated a cutoff of 30. Those percentages describe the discriminant analysis; they should not be presented as universal accuracy estimates for every DES-II ≥30 screen. [3]

Read the figures with their study context

Two different analyses in the 1993 DES study Discriminant analysis in a psychiatric subgroup of 883 gave 76 percent sensitivity and 85 percent specificity. A separate analysis considered a cutoff of 30 and estimated 17 percent positive predictive value under its base-rate assumptions. These are distinct analyses, not one universal set of DES-II cutoff statistics.
The 1993 study reported distinct discriminant and cutoff analyses. Their statistics must not be combined as one universal DES-II accuracy claim. [3]

Why predictive value depends on the setting

The paper's base-rate calculations estimated that 17% of people scoring at least 30 would have the target disorder under the conditions considered. A positive screen was therefore not equivalent to that diagnosis. The estimate is not a current diagnostic probability for someone completing DES-II on LuriaLab. [3]

  • Sample: a psychiatric population is different from a general website audience.
  • Target: detecting one disorder is different from describing dissociation broadly.
  • Method: a statistical classification function and a fixed numerical cutoff are distinct analyses.

Check whether the evidence fits the use

Match the instrument to the assessment question Check the purpose first, then age and self-report needs, language and version, and the setting in which the measure was studied. Availability of a translation or a website age listing is not itself evidence of equivalent validity.
Findings from one version and population should not automatically be applied to another.

What remains uncertain

The DES contains both common absorption and more disruptive experiences. Later instrument-development work, including development of the DSS, addressed a different emphasis on clinically disruptive symptoms. Measures can therefore correlate without being interchangeable. [4]

The selected studies do not establish a universal meaningful-change threshold, diagnose trauma exposure or validate every translated online implementation. Interpretation still needs the actual experiences, context and appropriate clinical assessment.

For the practical meaning of a mean score, read the results guide.

References

  1. Bernstein & Putnam (1986). Development, reliability, and validity of a dissociation scale. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 174, 727–735. DOI: 10.1097/00005053-198612000-00004.
  2. Carlson & Putnam (1993). An update on the Dissociative Experience Scale. Dissociation, 6, 16–27. Paper and DES-II form.
  3. Carlson et al. (1993). Validity of the DES in screening for multiple personality disorder: a multicenter study. American Journal of Psychiatry, 150, 1030–1036. DOI: 10.1176/ajp.150.7.1030.
  4. Carlson et al. (2018). Development and validation of the Dissociative Symptoms Scale. Assessment, 25, 84–98.
Menu